It has been calculated that the Centre of Registers provided data for 330 million euro, while receiving only 740 thousand euro for it or in other terms, just 0.22% of its value. The minister of transport and communications says that this shows the scale of how thoughtlessly the data was provided.
In his presentation of the audit results, Minister of Transport and Communications Rokas Masiulis stated that a scheme was formed, which granted exclusive conditions for several related companies. They were allowed to take pole positions in the data sales market, while at the same time, other companies paid the usual 27 cent fee for a unit of data.
“Exclusive conditions to obtain data were granted to them [the companies] – the pricing that should have applied did not, that is to say instead of 27 cents for a unit of data, the cost was 6 cents and sometimes even 3 cents for a unit of data. Furthermore, in some cases conditions were made to access unlimited data for a subscription,” R. Masiulis said.
It is calculated that just due to the provision of data for 6 cents instead of 27, the Centre of Registers lost 1.3 million euro in income.
R. Masiulis noted that the involved companies’ names cannot be revealed at the moment while law enforcement has not concluded its investigations. It was only mentioned that one company has around 50 staff and exclusively obtained data on deaths for 3 cents each. Also, exclusive conditions were granted to two small companies, which had up to 4 staff each. Questions arise whether such small companies were capable of processing the massive amount of data received or if they did not transfer it to third parties, thus failing to ensure data security. It was specified that in 2017, a foreign company also appeared, which took interest in citizen registry data and was also granted exclusive conditions.
Centre of Registers head Saulius Urbanavičius stated that action has already been taken due to this practice. The contracts with data recipients that were found faulty were changed by the end of last year. He also stated that it was agreed for large data recipients to receive different prices and pricing has been prepared already, pending approval from the government. It is stated that it was prepared based on business expectations and the most expensive services will be paper-based inquiries. The cheapest service will be digital data transfer, from system to system.
The Centre of Registers also intends to contact the State Data Protection Inspectorate for further evaluations of the content and security of data provided by the Centre of Registers so far.
The Special Investigation Service is continuing a pre-trial investigation launched in September 2018 on potential abuses in granting exclusive conditions for private companies to receive registry data. In September 2018, the Ministry of Transport and Communications together with the Centre of Registers’ new management launched an audit of the centre, which sought to evaluate unsuitably low pricing provided by the state enterprise to certain large companies for its data.
Delfi reminds that audit has also been performed regarding the e-health system. The Centre of Registers contacted the prosecutors regarding potentially illegal actions and property damaged caused by them after performing the audit in December 2018. During the audit, it was uncovered that the system’s flaws must have been known already in 2015, however no one took to fixing them at the time. The audit of the e-health system showed that three companies may have been granted exclusive public procurement conditions and one’s staff later were given employment in the Centre of Registers, receiving pay from tax payer’s money.